A two-bedroom condominium on the Amphitheatre and a new five-bedroom house a short walk from the Beach Club are very different purchases. One costs a little over $3.2 million. The other costs more than $11 million. In the developer's fall 2026 pricing, though, a square foot of the condo can cost close to what a square foot of the house costs.
That changes how to read the Alys Beach market. The portals show the town's median price, and the median mixes condos, courtyard houses and Gulf-view homes into one number. The developer's own current asking prices show something else. Across very different products, the price per foot stays within a fairly narrow band. The large gaps in total price come from size and from which side of Scenic Highway 30A the home is on, not from a premium for one kind of home over another.
The clearest set of numbers comes from Alys Beach's own Fall 2026 Alys Insider, the developer's quarterly update. It features three single-family homes. The Dannelly & Varian condominiums at Town Center are the fourth data point. Their second-phase release is listed on the official development page.
| Property | Location | Asking price | Conditioned sq. ft. | Approx. ask per sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 195 North Charles Street | North of 30A | $8,875,000 | 4,415 | $2,010 |
| 117 Elbow Beach Road | South of 30A | $11,295,000 | 4,378 | $2,580 |
| 185 Elbow Beach Road | South of 30A | $14,615,000 | 5,910 | $2,473 |
| The Dannelly & Varian, 2BR and 3BR | Town Center | $3,216,674 to $5,150,456 | about 1,505 to 1,997 | roughly $2,020 to $2,600 |
The town's own listing for 195 North Charles Street places it north of 30A. These are asking prices as published in fall 2026, not closed sales. The per-foot figures are simple division. For the condos, the range comes from matching the published price bands to the floor-plan sizes, not to specific units. The official Dannelly floor plans list a three-bedroom at 1,997 conditioned square feet plus 506 unconditioned square feet, and a two-bedroom at 1,594 conditioned. The Varian plans list two-bedrooms from 1,505 to 1,521 square feet and three-bedrooms from 1,977 to 1,984. Both plan sets describe their areas as approximate.
Even with those caveats, the pattern holds. The condo range starts near the North Charles Street rate and reaches the top of the two new houses south of 30A, which ask about $2,470 and $2,580 per foot.
Between the two sides of 30A, the single-family homes differ by about 23% to 28% per square foot. The North Charles Street home and 117 Elbow Beach Road are almost the same size, 4,415 and 4,378 square feet. Their asking prices are $2.42 million apart.
The homes are similar in other ways too. 195 North Charles Street is a Christ & Associates design overlooking Papilio Park and its olive grove. It has more than 1,100 square feet of terraces and loggias and a third-floor star deck with a fire pit. 117 Elbow Beach Road is new construction by Gary Justiss Architect. It has a courtyard pool, summer kitchens and a rooftop with Gulf views. Both have Venetian plaster and courtyard pools, and both were built to the same town standards. The big measurable difference is the side of the highway, which puts one home in sight of the Gulf.
185 Elbow Beach Road shows that the per-foot rate holds as homes get larger. At 5,910 square feet, the Chancey Design home is the largest of the three and the most expensive at $14,615,000. It is sold fully furnished, with an elevator, 13-foot ceilings and a rooftop terrace facing the Gulf. Its asking price per foot is lower than 117 Elbow Beach Road's. On this street, a bigger home adds to the total price but does not raise the per-foot rate.
Under this pricing, a Town Center condo is not reliably a cheaper square foot. Its estimated range runs from about the North Charles Street rate up to the rates of the new houses south of 30A, and the three-bedroom plans sit at the upper end.
Location is what the condo buyer pays for. The Dannelly & Varian sits at the northeast end of the Amphitheatre, among the Town Center's restaurants and shops. Michael G. Imber of San Antonio designed it. The building has 18 residences in total, six three-bedrooms and twelve two-bedrooms. After a presale release, the second phase brings nine of them to market. Town Center is also where the town has added the most this year. Indaco's arrival this summer increased visits to Town Center, according to the developer's fall letter. That letter also mentions Rowan and an expanded KREWE location coming to The Liner building.
At the upper end of that range, a condo buyer pays the Gulf-side per-foot rate for a front door near the Amphitheatre rather than a view of the water. The total price is lower because there are fewer square feet.
Part of the reason the per-foot prices are so close is that the biggest amenity in town is the same for every owner. Alys Beach describes more than $100 million in amenities, including Caliza Pool & Restaurant, the ZUMA Wellness Center and Racquet Sports Facility, and The Silva's Summerhouse Pavilion, restaurant, bar and pool. Owners and their guests can use all of them. The town's homeowner amenities page describes the Gulf-front Beach Club as exclusive to Alys Beach homeowners.
Beach access works the same way. The town's beach page lists the beach accesses at Gulf Green, Turtle Bale and Béla Gray for homeowners and vacation-rental guests. Homeowners also get exclusive access through the Beach Club. The $3.2 million two-bedroom and the $14.6 million Elbow Beach Road home therefore buy into the same owner amenities. What separates them is space, view, privacy and a private courtyard pool. A buyer who wants the Beach Club and the walk to Town Center can get both in either product.
These asking prices have to be read against how much of Alys Beach the developer still has to sell. In the Fall 2026 Alys Insider, the developer reported that 73% of all properties currently planned for the town had sold as of October 1, 2026. Real estate sales through the third quarter of 2026 were up 46% over 2025. The same letter said rental revenue in summer 2026 was up nearly 9% over summer 2025.
The remaining developer inventory is spread across a few different products. Somersisle Terrace, a collection of row homes south of 30A, was nearing completion in the fall issue. North of the highway, Phase IV, the GG Block, is a neighborhood of cottage homes and gardens around a wetland park and nature preserve. The town describes its setting as more country than town. Pricing for it goes through the sales team. According to the letter, several more developments are in design charrettes.
So the next phases include a north-of-30A neighborhood, a part of town where the current per-foot ask has been lower. With most of the planned town already sold, the cheaper per-foot side of the highway is also where much of the developer's remaining new inventory is planned.
All of the figures above sit well below the town's top sale. PR Newswire reported in late May 2026 that 53 Sea Castle Alley, a Gulf-front home, sold for $28 million, a record for the community. Its buyer had bought the homesite for $9.475 million in 2022. Mansion Global put the house at 5,124 interior square feet. That works out to roughly $5,464 per square foot, about twice the rate of the Elbow Beach Road homes a short walk inland. A front-row Gulf lot is a separate market. Below that tier, Alys Beach's prices follow the per-foot band in the table.
The developer's fall letter said Alys Beach weathered Hurricane Isaias well. It added that the town's dunes and beach accesses need replenishment and restoration, and that planning for the work is underway. Buyers touring this winter may see some of that work around the beach accesses.
No. They are the developer's published asking prices from fall 2026. Resale homes are priced and negotiated one at a time, and recent closings by property type are the right check for any particular home.
The town describes the Beach Club as exclusive to Alys Beach homeowners. Owners and guests can use Caliza, ZUMA and The Silva. Before signing a contract, confirm the access that comes with the specific residence.
The North Charles Street and Elbow Beach Road homes are close in size and finish. The Gulf-side homes have rooftop Gulf views and are near the Beach Club, and that location accounts for most of the difference.
Yes. As of October 1, 2026, the developer reported 73% of currently planned properties sold. The Dannelly & Varian second phase, Somersisle Terrace and Phase IV / GG Block make up the current pipeline.
Spears Group tracks those numbers home by home across Alys Beach and the rest of 30A. Request a complimentary market valuation and luxury marketing plan, and we will show you where your Alys Beach home or target purchase falls in the current per-foot band.